“mind” the gap


According to this article from New Scientist, creationists have a new strategy in their never ending push to get religion into science class. They are trying hard to convince people that the existence of consciousness cannot be explained by reference to the physical brain. Therefore the mind must be “spiritual” in nature. It must be heavenly. Like a multitude of new agers, some are saying that quantum physics somehow makes this all true. (See my rant about such ridiculous misuse of science at the end of this earlier post.)

Anyway, it’s all another “god of the gaps” argument. If science can’t explain it yet, then god did it. An old version of this argument is that thunder and lightning must be evidence that the gods are angry. More recently the argument was that bacterial flagellum (the little propellers bacteria use to move) could never be explained by evolution, so god must have made them. Of course, just like thunder and lightning, we now actually have a pretty good idea of how flagellum came to exist.

This whole notion that whatever we don’t understand yet is proof of god just isn’t going to fly. In this particular instance, a little time spent in an Alzheimers ward or a head trauma clinic might convince you that one’s state of consciousness is directly related to the physical brain. Meanwhile, science is making gradual progress in understanding the brain and there’s no reason to suppose we won’t someday know the physical factors that create consciousness.

Creationists: mind the gap in your understanding of reality. The rest of you: be wary of attempts to degrade science education–we can’t afford it.

Extra reading assignment: An in-depth discussion of the philosophical and scientific issues surrounding mind/brain can be found on the always excellent Neurologica Blog. There are posts before and after the one I’ve linked to that also address the issue.


2 thoughts on ““mind” the gap

  1. I like your blog header pic. I didn’t realize that you knew the Easter Island guys on a personal basis! You’ll have to introduce me to them sometime ..

    Anyway, most people cannot wrap their heads around the concept of what “random changes over millions of years” really means. They cannot grasp that many millions of years really is more than sufficient time for trillions of “random mutations” to occur. Given “enough” time and “enough” changes, darwinian evolution has no problem generating any biological structure you wish.

    *any* mutation that doesn’t kill its possessor (or detract from its possessor’s ability to procreate) will get passed on. That’s all “evolution” needs to operate. Small changes add up over time to macro-features.

    As to “consciousness” .. no one can demostrate evidence of gods or God either ..

    “Faith!” and “I believe this is so” are truly meaningless as evidence of anything.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s